Calvedri
article

Calvedri – Why mapping plausible futures beats forecasting

Calvedri – Why mapping plausible futures beats forecasting

Why the quality of your research matters more than the quantity of your information

Most investors spend a great deal of energy trying to work out what the market will do next. This is understandable — uncertainty is uncomfortable, and a confident prediction feels like solid ground. But the honest truth is that no one, regardless of how sophisticated their tools or how extensive their experience, can reliably tell you what a share price, a sector, or the broader economy will do over the next year. What experienced investors can do, however, is think carefully about the range of plausible futures and ask a more useful question for each one: what would need to be true for this outcome to unfold? This shift in thinking — from prediction to possibility — is the foundation of scenario analysis. Rather than committing to a single view of the world and defending it, you hold several views simultaneously and stay alert to which one the evidence is beginning to support. It is a more honest way of engaging with uncertainty, and over time it tends to produce more thoughtful decisions than chasing the most confident forecast you can find.

The practical starting point is to sketch out two or three meaningfully different versions of how a situation might develop. These should not be slight variations on the same theme — they should reflect genuinely different assumptions about the underlying forces at work. If you are trying to understand the prospects of a local retailer, for example, one scenario might assume that consumer spending holds up reasonably well as inflation eases and employment remains stable. A second might assume that household budgets stay under pressure for longer than expected, suppressing discretionary spending. A third might involve some structural shift — a change in how people shop, or a competitor entering the market — that changes the rules of the game entirely. The point is not to decide which scenario is most likely and then ignore the others. The point is to ask, for each scenario, what conditions would need to exist for it to become reality, and what early signs might you observe if the world were moving in that direction. This turns your research into something active and responsive rather than a one-time judgment you make and then defend.

What makes scenario analysis genuinely useful is the discipline of identifying signposts — the observable developments that would tell you which scenario is gaining ground. These might be things like trends in consumer confidence surveys, changes in a company's reported inventory levels, shifts in the language that management uses when discussing their outlook, or broader economic indicators that are publicly available. None of these signals is definitive on its own, but together they help you update your understanding as new information arrives. This is quite different from the common habit of interpreting every piece of news as confirmation of whatever view you already hold. When you have mapped out multiple scenarios in advance, you are forced to ask whether new information is genuinely consistent with your preferred view or whether it fits better with one of the alternatives. That kind of structured self-questioning is one of the most valuable things an individual investor can practise, and it costs nothing except the willingness to be honest with yourself about what you do not know.

One of the less obvious benefits of this approach is what it does to your assumptions. Every investment thesis rests on a set of beliefs about how the world works — beliefs about interest rates, about consumer behaviour, about management quality, about competitive dynamics. Most of the time these beliefs sit in the background, unexamined. Scenario analysis forces them into the open. When you try to write down what would need to be true for a particular outcome to occur, you quickly discover which of your assumptions are well-supported and which are really just hopes dressed up as analysis. This is not a comfortable process, but it is a productive one. It also helps you size your uncertainty appropriately — recognising that some scenarios are more plausible than others without pretending that the less likely ones cannot happen. South African investors in particular operate in an environment where political, regulatory, and macroeconomic conditions can shift in ways that are difficult to anticipate, which makes this kind of structured thinking especially worthwhile. The goal is not to eliminate uncertainty but to understand it well enough that you are not caught completely off guard when the world does not behave the way you expected.